Tigran Mansurian: The composer must remain sincere and truthful

29 January 2020, 14:00
Tigran Mansurian: The composer must remain sincere and truthful

On the next day after the powerful experience I had gotten from the performance of Requiem by the Armenian composer Tigran Mansurian, I had the opportunity to meet its creator. The fragile, gentle and sincere music thus foreshadowed me of its author, with whom I spent a few precious moments in the director's lounge of the Besední dům in Brno in a very friendly conversation.

The production of your Requiem by the Brno Philharmonic was not only the Czech premiere in the broadest sense of the word – the concert was performed by Anja Petersen together with Andrew Redmond, moreover under the baton of Alexander Liebreich. All of the above also stood at the premiere of the work in 2011 and participated in its highly appraised recording. Was this your wish for the work to be rendered in the most authentic form possible, or did we just have the best of luck in Brno?

Already the first rehearsal for the Berlin premiere of 2011 was decisive for the way I perceive this composition. When you first hear what only sounds in your mind until then, the whole composition translates into a real sound. It is always an extremely interesting process and always unique. And in the case of Requiem, what I had until then perceived only internally, and what maestro Liebreich achieved, merged into one. And not much has changed since then. Of course, it is sometimes necessary to look at seemingly tiny details, like when we recorded this work for ECM Records. (Also under the baton of Alexander Liebreich and with Münchener Kammerorchester and RIAS Kammerchor Berlin – note by LP). At such a moment, everything becomes much clearer and a number of things emerge to the surface, concerning both the choir and the orchestra, and especially the soloists.


Does this also happen when Requiem is led by other conductors? 

That is for sure – the composition already lives its own life, completely independent of the composer.

How do you perceive the differences between the premiere and subsequent performances of the composition?

I usually try to have the performers that we had at the Berlin premiere to be present also under the direction of another conductor. I want the outcome to be as close as possible to that of Alexander Liebreich in Berlin. And now we also have a recording that could make it easier for new conductors to work in this direction.

And now you made a trip with the artists to our Moravian metropolis personally ...

Well, the truth is, when it comes to Requiem, I usually don't travel anywhere any more. If some new work is to be performed, then my presence is probably desirable. But here I rather enjoy the position of a guest. When it is a festival and I am, for example, a composer in residence, I attend the performances. As for some of my older pieces, I usually get to know about them on the day after, from the newspapers. But I don't mind this greatly. In fact: I don't like to travel at all.


What eventually made you travel to Brno?

I was here in 1964 when it was still Czechoslovakia... and I was still young. I had a very nice relationship with several local personalities of musical life. Marek Kopelent and his Musica Viva Pragensis premièred one of my compositions in Prague. But I wasn't there, for obvious reasons. But I also kept in touch with other people. There was for example the composer Ivana Loudová, who I had met in Yerevan, Armenia. She was a very noble lady with unconventional insight into Armenian culture. And all these memories, as well as the invitations I received from the Brno Philharmonic and Alexander Liebreich, eventually overwhelmed me. Czech music has a special place in my heart, especially Janáček. Now that I have spent those few days here, I hope to take away a piece of Janáček with me.

How did you perceive the combination of Bach's cantatas with your Requiem ?

It is an interesting combination, but it had nothing to do with me. It was the work of the people preparing the programme. It is clear that in the preparation of a plan for the whole season, a number of unbelievably complex processes are under way, which are behind the broader idea of ​​the whole. For me personally, the programme reflected post-modern tendencies in music and art in general. When we premiered the composition, we had Mozart's Requiem suited with it.

If you had to choose something else, what do you think might be played in the first half of the evening?

Well, in terms solely of desire and not practicality, I would feel nice in the company of Arvo Pärt. We had a similarly shaped concert in Lisbon. The first half was Pärt, the second was my Requiem, but as far as older composers are concerned, I have no idea.

You are a composer of art and incidental music; how do you distinguish these different media in your compositional practice? How do you approach them during the composing process?

It's not a simple relationship at all. Often I was obliged to write incidental music, and when that was the case, I had to take full responsibility for the whole result. It is often difficult to translate the meanings of certain things into film music and it requires a special, very unique way of thinking. It's like becoming another person. And the transitions between this point of view and the unfettered composing, in which one is solely responsible for himself, have often been very challenging.


You composed the last film score for The Tango of Our Childhood in 1984; would incidental music be still attractive for you today? 

Exactly, it was the last film. I won't write any more incidental music anymore. Even so, I wrote quite a lot of music for films. What is featured outside the films is only a fraction of what I composed for these purposes. I also wrote music for theatre, but I never included these compositions in my “collection”. I never took them out of their context.

And is there any type of film that would persuade you to the opposite?

Sometimes I watch movies in the evening, and quite recently I watched a very unusual film by a British director whose name I can't remember now. However, the film itself was extremely interesting – the two protagonists did not share a common language, each speaking a different language without the possibility of a translator. They were a man and a woman, and they were accompanied by poetry. That is something you don't see much in movies - that they are dominated by poetry instead of spoken word. And this synthesis was unexpectedly fresh and interesting to me. In this context, music is able to add yet another strong artistic level to a composition. Maybe something unusual would be the way for me.

Do you perceive any significant changes in your own musical style? What are your major turning points?

When I graduated, I had to renew myself, completely rebuild myself. I had to become “Boulez's student”. I had to get to know Stockhausen and other leading composers of that time, their techniques, and compositions and so on. I was very far away from the world's music centres, where it was boiling with new music. It was a time when I composed the composition Interior for a string quartet. At that time, I read a book named Man's Place in Nature by Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, in which the author claims that the evolution and progress of man will increasingly become an internal matter of man descending into himself. So I wrote a composition that aims to reach that core, and that caught the attention of Pierre Boulez. Moreover, the work matched his aesthetic feeling, and eventually he had it produced in Paris. I still have no idea how he got to the score. After all, it was the time of the Soviet Union... And then one day I met Boulez. He expressed appreciation for the composition and gave me the names of other composers who were devoted to similar music. And at that moment I understood that I had “passed the test” and could continue to seek myself and my artistic expression.

You taught music theory until 1986; were there also people interested in studying composition with you? Do young composers ask you for advice?

I taught composition for a short time, but I realized that each composer must carry his own cross. And it is impossible for one to help the other by himself. So at least I came to realize that I wasn't the right one for that. I was not able to enter one's unfinished composition. And so I only really did the teaching only for a short time. I simply  could not reach the necessary connection with the students.

Composers often use their works to communicate deeper non-musical reality and the works often relate directly to the current social or cultural situation. After all, your Requiem was created as a reminder of the victims of the Armenian genocide. Is there any inner quality that art should always have? 

It is my deepest conviction and at the same time my most important requirement that the composer must remain sincere and truthful. For me, this is the most fundamental thing, regardless of the work itself. This achievement, this becoming the materialization of the truth, means that there is no space left for anything outside the realm of music. I myself am quite reluctant to programme music and I do not even feel the need to listen to it. Of course there are common points between music and life as we experience it, but it is such a fragile and delicate relationship that there is no room for programme motives. For me it is important who wrote the music. But the most important thing is what the music enthusiast feels, the one that had grown in me since my childhood. And I try to combine these two things – the music-loving me and my professional self – into one, into profession and love. And from this point of view, things beyond the reach of music have pretty little to do with love.

Tigran Mansurian / Photo by Jiří Sláma



No comment added yet..

“Every theatre is a madhouse, but opera is the ward for the incurable,” claimed Franz von Dingelstedt, the first director of the Court Opera House in Vienna. And he was right, for once someone’s fallen in love with opera, that’s it. Opera’s a stepchild of the Renaissance, with a Baroque wet nurse: it was on the cusp between these two great eras that the idea of purely sung theatre saw the light of day. Step by step, composers taught the art of singing to classical gods and brave women, Christian heroes and pagan enchantresses, a Seville barber, a Babylonian king and the Czech Mařenka and Jeník. But it was only here in Brno, thanks to Leoš Janáček, that truly psychological musical drama was born, drama that sees into a person’s heart. Today the Brno opera company has its home in a theatre named after Janáček, mounts a major festival devoted to the city’s most famous composer every two years, and has set its sights very high. “The more opera is dead, the more it flourishes,” pronounced the philosopher Slavoj Žižek when speaking of this fanatically loved but just as fanatically rejected genre. By this measure, opera in Brno these days must have been dead at least a dozen times.  more

To write a guide to music in Brno in the past and present means digging deep into one’s own recollections and those of others as well as into sources with varying degrees of reliability, and as far as possible not believing anything automatically but always asking “Did this really happen just like that?” And in doing so, to be very, very suspicious of one’s own memory. Two basic questions that cropped up in connection with almost every sentence were “What is it about this band or that event that makes them special? Would someone who’s never been to Brno and has no ties with the city find it interesting?”  more

Trumpet player Jiří Kotača is the leader of a young, but very interesting and healthily ambitious big band named Cotatcha Orchestra. While this Brno-based orchestra is still waiting for its first album, Kotača recently released a CD with his smaller ensemble – the international Alf Carlsson/Jiří Kotača Quartet. The album is entitled Journeysmore

Due to the impact of extraordinary measures taken because of the Covid-19 pandemic on stakeholders of the cultural and creative industries in Brno, Brno leaders and the Department of Culture of the Brno City Municipality are working intensively on a set of precautions for minimizing the damages. At the same time, communication is conducted on all levels of public administration, predominantly in collaboration with the Institut umění – Divadelní ústav [Arts and Theatre Institute], which is  mapping the situation on the nationwide level. Until 22 March 2020 you can help assess the current situation by means of an online survey (the link is provided below). Further steps will be taken according to the results of the survey.  more

The fourth subscription evening prepared by the Brno Philharmonic for the chief conductor's series called Philharmonic at Stadion and Janáček Theatre is an exceptional dramaturgical feat. The programme entitled "Pictures at an Exhibition", based on Modest Petrovich Mussorgsky's initial composition, combines additional works originated in and inspired by painting: The Frescoes of Piero della Francesca by Bohuslav Martinů, and Mathis der Maler, a symphony by Paul Hindemith. Sounding painting is accompanied by unique, music-illustrated visualisations of Cori O’Lan in collaboration with Ars Electronica. This week's difficult situation, not only for cultural institutions, was managed by the Brno Philharmonic promptly and with a great acclaim. Much like Cirk La Putyka on the day before, the Philharmonic decided not to cancel the performance at the Janáček Theatre and to broadcast the music and visualisations on 12 March from the Besední dům live on the web and on social networks.  more

The story of fateful love of the beautiful courtesan Marguerite and her sweetheart Armand, as we know it from the autobiographical prose The Lady of the Camellias by Alexander Dumas Jr., need not be largely introduced. One of the most famous novels of the 19th century has already been subject to a number of remakes, and now the National Theatre Brno ballet ensemble also came up with a new modern concept of this story of pain, passion and self-sacrifice.  more

Last year, after several years of stagnation, Brno's folklore enthusiasts woke up again and began organizing gatherings with dulcimer music, folklore parties, etc. at several different venues. This is certainly gratifying. However, motivation, experiences and concepts differ. One of them is We <3 folklore in the Metro music bar.  more

Spontaneous joy of dancing is hiding behind the mysterious cry Šej-Haj-Hop! That is why the new school of Slovak folk dance in Brno chose it as its name. There are three friends behind it – Michal Janšto, Edita Borščová and Ondrej Mišík, who all met a few years ago at VSĽPT Poľana.  more

We know several singing cello players from the domestic music scene: Olin Nejezchleba, who recorded his first solo album at the age of fifty; Tara Fuki, which even consists of two singing cellists; and Natálie Velšmídová, who shone out bright with her folk song remakes at the end of the millennium. However, Pavel Čadek is the only true singer-songwriter in the sense that he writes his own songs and uses cello as his main (or even the only) accompanying instrument. Moreover, thanks to his classical music training and his past with The Eclipse, a harder cello group, he is able to work with the cello freshly and, above all, in a non-folk manner, and that is why his instrument sometimes plays more than just an accompanying role. Although his debut album would be sufficiently varied even with cello only, Pavel decided to work with more sophisticated arrangements and invited accordionist Ondřej Zámečník, cajon player Jakub Špiřík and some other guests in episode roles to the studio.  more

The singer Lizz Wright was born in 1980 to the family of a pastor. From childhood, gospel music was close to her, she used to sing in a choir and later began to adore additional originally Afro-American genres, such as soul, blues and jazz. In November 2019 at the Blues Alive festival in Šumperk she performed with her own band, but in Brno she will be accompanied by the Brno Philharmonic along with a trio of Prague jazz performers (David Dorůžka – guitar, Tomáš Baroš – double bass, Daniel Šoltis – drums). The concert will take place on 3 May in the Janáček Theatre as part of the JAZZFESTBRNO 2020 festival.  more

On Friday 14 February, the Sono Centre in Brno hosted a genre-diversified festival, which was also a celebration of three decades of activity of three publishing branches, which we associate with the original simple name Indies Records. Over the years, Indies Records has divided itself into three separate labels with three distinct edition catalogues – Indies MG, Indies Scope and Indies Happy Trails, which are operated by the personalities of Miloš Gruber, Milan Páleš and Jaromír Kratochvíl.  more

A fateful comedy, the third part of a musical trilogy or a fantasy musical. These attributes define Paradise, a new authorial piece from the workshop of Zdenek Merta and Stanislav Moša. Their ninth joint work in the field of music theatre was premiered yesterday on the big stage of the Brno City Theatre. The result is embarrassing.  more

Director, librettist and stage designer David Radok and composer, but also chief conductor of the opera ensemble Marko Ivanović created the authorial work for the opera ensemble of the National Theatre Brno. The opera The Monument, which was premiered yesterday, tells the story of sculptor Otakar Švec (1892–1955), whose design in 1955 was a portent of Stalin's monument at Letná. The title roles in the Janáček Theatre were performed by: Stanislav Sem (Sculptor), Markéta Cukrová (Wife), Roman Hoza (Colleague) and Ondřej Koplík (Minister of Culture). The solo parts were complemented by the Opera Choir, the Czech Academic Choir and the Brno Children's Choir. The Janáček Opera Orchestra was directed by the author of the music Marko Ivanović.  more

The cellist Josef Klíč, concert master of the Janáček Theatre in Brno, is close to classical music as well as underground, works together with poets and wrote several essential compositions exploring the border between contemporary and alternative music. His new solo album, Josef Klíč & His One Man Cello Squad, contains songs without words, which is, as Klíč pointed out in an interview last year for our server, a form that "existed already in the Renaissance times". And he explains: "A song without words is a composition that you can put your own lyrics into. It has a melody and you can sing the lyrics to it for yourself. Therefore, it must be a song with a powerful melody."   more

On the next day after the powerful experience I had gotten from the performance of Requiem by the Armenian composer Tigran Mansurian, I had the opportunity to meet its creator. The fragile, gentle and sincere music thus foreshadowed me of its author, with whom I spent a few precious moments in the director's lounge of the Besední dům in Brno in a very friendly conversation.  more


A new broadcasting studio has been set up in the premises of the former penitentiary on Cejl Street, nowadays called Káznice, which will broadcast live concerts, theatre performances, lectures, discussions and even religious masses. The premiere broadcast has been announced for this evening, featuring Tomáš Vtípil.  more

The Cotatcha Orchestra big band members have just released the single A Very Old Lady Driving a Ferrari. Given the current situation, they did not make the recording in a studio. Everyone recorded their part at home.  more

TIC Brno responds to the current state of society and culture by launching an online project entitled (ni)KAM v Brně [(no)WHERE TO in Brno], which follows on the printed KAM (WHERE TO) magazine. The portal will gather and promote cultural activities in Brno so that supporters of culture can stay together even during this quarantine period.  more

As soon as this Sunday, the Czech Radio Brno will release a programme named Sedmikrásky na nebi (Daisies in the Sky), featuring live commenting of the sky. The show is developing as a result of collaboration with the Brno Observatory and Planetarium, and Jiří Dušek, director of Brno Observatory and Planetarium, will appear as a guest.  more

Městské divadlo Brno [MdB, Brno City Theatre] presented the titles it is preparing for the 2020/2021 season. The Music Scene is anticipating musicals such as Pretty Woman, Jane Eyre and a fairy tale Sněhurka a já [Snow White and I].  more

Singer Eva Pilarová, a native of Brno, died today 14 March 2020. She was 80 years old.  more

This Thursday and Friday, Brno Philharmonic will present a programme entitled Pictures at an Exhibition, which will feature three great music pieces accompanied by visualisations of Cori O´Lan. These were created  in collaboration with Ars Electronica, an organisation focusing on the use of latest technologies in art. The concerts will be conducted by  Dennis Russell Davies.  more

The National Security Council today decided to cancel all sporting, cultural and religious events for  more than  100 participants with effect from tonight,  10 March 2020.  more

The Ondráš Military Art Ensemble is hiring a dancer for the professional section of its ensemble. Expected start of employment is 3 February 2020.  more

The Janáček Opera ensemble is preparing the world premiere of a piece written specifically for it. The Monument is a tailor-made work for the stage of the Janáček Theatre, a big orchestra, ten soloists and three choirs: the opera choir, the Czech Academic Choir and the Brno Children's Choir. The opera production is being created under the direction of David Radok, who also wrote the libretto, while the music was written by the composer and chief conductor of the Brno opera ensemble Marko Ivanović. Svatopluk Sem, Markéta Cukrová, Roman Hoza and others will appear as soloists.  more